
The type of charter decides who pays for fuel and port costs, who holds commercial control of the vessel and which party receives cargo owners’ claims. Settle these lines before you sign, not during a dispute.
Three forms, three ways of sharing risk
Voyage charter. Under a Voyage Charter, the Shipowner places the vessel at the charterer’s disposal for one specified voyage. Commercial decisions, risk and operating costs stay with the owner, who earns Freight in return. The Charterer supplies the cargo and pays the agreed Freight.
Time charter. Under a Time Charter, maintenance, repairs, crew and the risk of marine casualties stay with the owner, who must insure their own interests. In return, the owner hands the vessel’s earning capacity to the charterer for daily Hire. The charterer pays for fuel, port dues, berth and access waterway costs, commissions and loading labour, and is responsible for the correct stowage of the cargo.
Bareboat charter. Under a Bareboat / Demise Charter, full control of the vessel passes to the charterer, together with its legal and financial responsibility. In almost every respect, the charterer then stands in the owner’s position.
Commercial control with the charterer, navigation with the master
Under a time charter, commercial decisions pass to the charterer unless the contract expressly provides otherwise. Navigation and technical management of the ship, however, stay with the master, who decides on behalf of the owner. In English case law, Lord Hobhouse in Whistler v Kawasaki did not treat a time charter as a contract of carriage. They described it as a contract for the services of a crewed ship.
Practical consequence. Under a voyage charter, the owner is usually bound only to take the customary route and carries no obligation to achieve a specific speed. Under a time charter, an Utmost Despatch clause is common. Write the speed, the fuel consumption and the party who decides on them expressly into the Charter Party. Document the charterer’s obligation to redeliver the vessel in suitable condition as well, through an On-hire / Off-hire Survey at the start and end of the charter.
Who is the carrier towards the cargo owner?
The relationship between owner and charterer is governed by the terms of the Charter Party. Rules such as the Hague-Visby Rules usually apply between these two only when a clause in the contract incorporates them. Towards third parties, these rules treat the Carrier as the owner or the charterer who has made the contract of carriage with the Shipper.
Time charterer’s risk. A voyage charterer is not usually regarded as the carrier, but a time charterer may be. Since the mid-1980s, Canadian maritime courts have held a time charterer to be the carrier where several indicators are present: their name appears on the Bill of Lading, they signed the bill on the master’s behalf, or they received funds relating to the cargo. A Demise Clause does not remove this risk entirely either. This status can decide the outcome of a case, particularly in cargo delivery claims and when one of the parties cannot pay.
Checklist. Before any Bill of Lading is issued, settle three things: whose name appears on it, who signs it, and into whose account the freight is paid.
If you are weighing a charter or a sale and want these points reviewed before you sign, search Shipo Market, list your vessel for free, or contact Pooria Adli. We will be glad to help.
Contact:Dr. Mehrshad Kouhestani's page
